Thursday, January 19, 2006

The Giver by Lois Lowry

Book Title: THE GIVER
Author: Lois Lowry
Published by Bantam Double Day Dell Books for Young Readers, New York, USA
Printed 1994
Number of Words: 485
Suggestion for Title: Choices We Make


All certified bookworms know that the mark of a great book is not in its length but in how it has changed your point of view. Some stories seem to go on and on while adding every possible twist in the plot, and yet you remain unaffected by it. Meanwhile, there are some books out there which are short but totally changes the way you see the world. They cut across all genres - across all generations even – in its telling of one pure story. This is exactly what Lois Lowry had done in her award-winning book The Giver. In 180 pages, she relates to us the story of a boy who lived in a perfect world and his discovery of what humanity has given up to gain the ideal society.

This book has been around for ages. In fact, I first read it when I was eleven years old and I loved it so much that I must have reread it a hundred times since then. The story is about Jonas, who lives in a world where there is no pain and suffering. There are rules for everything, and everyone follows them to the letter. Everything is pre-selected – their parents, their jobs, their spouses. No one is capable of making wrong choices since there are no choices to speak of at all. There is no color, no snow, rain or sun – there is just Sameness. There are no a strong emotions either – the words enraged or jealous has become obsolete, as much as the word love has become meaningless.

What’s striking about this book is the solidity of Lowry’s crafted world. All the solutions presented to solve most of Man’s modern malaise are believable and even reasonable. And as the carefully constructed system of their society unravels, it becomes more chilling to see that what Jonas’s people had to give up to achieve the perfect society was, in fact, their humanity.

As the story progresses, it becomes clear that the ideal community is not such a distant reality for us after all. But what would we be willing to give up? It’ll be great to have everything easy, but who would we be if we never knew pain or suffering? Can existing that way be ever called living at all? These are surprisingly hard questions raised from such a short book.

It’s too bad that The Giver is technically categorized as fiction for young adults. Yes, the story is set in another world which isn’t like our own yet. But children aren’t the only ones who would love this story. I actually believe that it’s the adults who should be reading the book. Anyone who ever thought they could make do without problems should read this book. Everyone who ever wondered what makes us human should read this book. Hmm… actually, every carbon-based life form who could read should read this book. And I think, that’s enough said.

The Gift by Patrick O' Leary

* I submitted this review to a friend of mine who was editor of a magazine. Unfortunately, publishing of the mag did not pull through. Am just placing this here for memento's sake.


Book Title: THE GIFT
Author: Patrick O’Leary
Published by Tom Doherty Associates (A Tor Book) , Fifth Avenue, New York
Printed 1997
Number of Words: 433 words
Suggestion for Title: Storytellers


“Death is the price. Magic is the gift.”

With this deceptively simple concept, Patrick O’Leary leads us right into an intricately woven tale inside tales inside tales. This book has all the elements of great fantasy interspersed throughout its pages – sorcery and shadows, greed and tragedy, and young men on a quest to save the world and their souls. But his book pushes the boundaries a little further, where the oddest characters and creatures mean the most sense. The beauty of this story is found in its rich prose and vivid description of everything that transpires in that world. It strings us along through a complex, and sometimes, tricky ride through the varying state of emotions of the main characters – loss, imitable sadness, confusion, anger and the joy of salvation.

It takes a little patience to read this book, but efforts are richly rewarded by the gems of wisdom found in so many of the little stories within the story itself. The need to savor the book gets stronger every time a page is turned, since it becomes apparent that this is not a piece of work to speed-read through. It must be relished; each word must be sampled piece by piece. The story is not in a hurry to end, for the end may just be another beginning after all.

My favorite realization in the whole book is that humans would just be animals without stories. Stories made us wonder and gave us wisdom. Stories gave us the beginnings of new yearnings and desires. Through stories, we can live many lives. It is our kind’s biggest piece of magic and it surrounds us all the time. But stories also gave us endings and our first encounter with little deaths. We began to truly understand what it means for things to come to an end. And with this book, we live and die a number of times.

As the final page is turned be prepared for the impulse to read parts of the book again. I attest that some of the stories inside are best read three times at the very least. In each rereading, something new surfaces from the lush imagery and provides us with a better understanding of what O’Leary was trying to describe to us. All in all, the world as related by the stories is ours to dream up. We are given a playground for the imagination. The deeper you delve, the more you learn how humans survived all these centuries. We are stronger because of our gift. Stories are all we have. And storytellers are who we are.